John Deere E170 vs S170: Which is the best in 2023?

John Deere tractor is a trusted and well-known brand in the outdoor power equipment industry.

If you’re in the market for a lawn tractor, consider two of their popular modelsthe John Deere E170 and S170.

These tractors are part of John Deere’s Select Series range, offering reliable performance and dependable features to help mow your lawn easier.

While both of these models offer great features, there are some key differences between them that you should consider before making your purchase.

Let’s examine what makes each of these lawn tractors unique. 

John Deere E170 vs John Deere S170: Quick Overview

Looking to upgrade your tractor? If so, consider the John Deere e170 and s170 models. 

While both tractors offer similar performancecapabilities, and features, some key differences can help you determine which is suitable for your needs.

Let’s take a closer look at the John Deere E170 vs. S170.

John Deere E170 Overview

The John Deere E170 is a powerful and reliable model with a wide 48-inch cutting deck that is perfect for mowing large spaces quickly and efficiently.

It also includes an ergonomic steering wheel with cruise control, adjustable seat height, and 13 cutting positions for precision mowing.

The engine on this model has 22 horsepower and hydrostatic transmission for smooth operation and easy maneuverability.

For added convenience, it also has an electric blade engagement system, so you don’t have to get off the tractor to engage or disengage the blades as needed. 

John Deere S170 Overview

The John Deere S170 is another excellent option if you need a powerful mower that can handle large areas quickly.

This one comes with a 48-inch cutting deck that provides even more coverage per pass.

The engine on this model has 24 horsepower for extra power when needed and an automatic transmission for effortless operation.

It also includes an adjustable suspension seat for added comfort during long mowing sessions and 12 levels of cut height adjustment for precise results every time. 

John Deere E170 vs S170: The comparison

If you are looking for a mower, chances are you’ve been looking at models from the famous John Deere tractor line.

The E170 and S170 are two of their most popular models and have many similarities, but some key differences set them apart.

Let’s look at the main elements that make these two mowers unique. 

Pros

Are you deciding between the John Deere e170 and the John Deere S170 lawn tractors? You’ll quickly realize that both have many benefits

The e170 offers a powerful 22-horsepower V-twin engine, perfect for tackling large lawns and hilly terrain. 

Additionally, you’ll benefit from an improved Operator Station Controls feature on the dash panel, making it easier to select performance settings and adjust speed settings while you’re mowing. 

Meanwhile, the John Deere S170 is equipped with a stronger 24-horsepower engine which supplies an even more powerful performance. 

It’s also outfitted with Smart Lawn Technology which allows for smart overgrowth detection and automatic passes for uneven terrain and slopes for increased safety. 

When it comes to cutting width, both mowers have 48-inch decks that are ideal for medium to large-sized yards.

The deck design is also similar on both tractors, with a deep dome shape that helps lift grass blades for better cutting performance.

An anti-scalp wheel is also included, helping protect your lawn from being torn up by the blades when going over bumps or uneven terrain. 

Both models have standard mulching capabilities, but only the S170 has an optional side discharge and rear bagging options.

Both tractors also feature cruise control, so you can keep a consistent speed without constantly adjusting the speed setting as you go along. 

Both models come with a 3-gallon fuel tank with plenty of capacity for most tasks around your yard. 

The larger fuel tank means fewer stops due to refueling, which saves time and makes it easier to complete larger jobs in one sitting. 

Additionally, both models feature a battery backup system which helps prevent any loss of power when changing out batteries or refueling mid-job. 

Cons

While the John Deere e170 and John Deere S170 models of ride-on mowers have many beneficial features, there are still some cons to consider when purchasing either model.

For instance, the standard consumer warranty policy fails to address potential breakdowns and malfunctions after a certain number of hours used. 

Additionally, the e170 only has the option of an electric PTO clutch, which may be inadequate for heavy-duty jobs

The S170 has hydraulic control over its PTO, protecting it from accidental misapplication. However, this is an added expense for those opting for the S170 model.

Differences between John Deere E170 and John Deere S170

1. Engine Size and Power 

The first significant difference between these two mowers is engine power

The E170 lawn tractor has a 22 horsepower (HP) V-Twin engine, whereas the S170 features a 24 HP engine.

If you need more power to cut through taller grass or tackle more challenging terrain, the S170 may be your best bet since it offers 2 extra horsepower. 

This might not sound like much of a difference, but it can make a huge difference when tackling tougher jobs or larger yards

2. Transmission

The second key difference between these two mowers is the transmission

The E170 has a hydrostatic transmission, which offers smooth operation and easy maneuverability. The S170, on the other hand, has an automatic transmission.

This means you don’t have to worry about manually shifting gears while operating it, as all the gear changes are done automatically.

3. Drive system

The drive system is another major factor when comparing these two tractors. 

The E170 lawn tractor has a manual transmissionand the S170 features an automatic transmission, making mowing much easier and more comfortable.

The manual transmission on the E170 requires you to shift gears manually while driving, while the automatic transmission of the S170 does this for you.

With the S170, you can focus more on mowing and less on shifting gears. 

4. Speed Settings 

The E170 has 6 speeds forward and reverse settings, while the S170 has 7 speeds. 

This allows you to customize your speed depending on the task at hand and ensure that you get optimal performance out of your machine without sacrificing too much time or energy.  

5. Wheelbase Width & Turning Radius 

When it comes to maneuverability, there are also some differences between these two models.

The wheelbase width of the E170 is 43 inches while the S170’s wheelbase width is 47 inches; this makes the latter slightly wider and more stable than its counterpart. 

Similarly, the turning radius of the E170 is 16 inches while on the other hand, while the turning radius of the S170 is 18 inches., making it slightly less maneuverable than its counterpart. 

6. Ease of Use

The E170 and S170 offer many convenient features that make mowing easier.

The E170 has an electric blade engagement system that makes it easy to start and stop the blades without getting off the tractor.

The S170 also offers this feature, but it takes things one step further with an adjustable suspension seat for added comfort and 12 cut height adjustments that allow you to get the perfect cut every time.

Ultimately, both models offer great features and reliable performance that make mowing your lawn easier.

7. Price Point 

Finally, the price point is one of the most important factors when deciding between these models

The E170 model retails for around $1,899, while the S170 model retails for around $2199.  

If budget isn’t an issue for you, opting for the higher-end model will get you more bang for your buck in terms of extra power and wider cutting area. 

John Deere E170 vs John Deere S170: Which one is the best? 

For homeowners looking to upgrade their current lawn tractor or purchase their first one, both John Deere’s E170 and S170 lawn tractors have powerful engines  capable of tackling challenging terrain, reliable performance, and plenty of features designed to make mowing your lawn easier than ever before. 

However, several key differences between these two machines can help you decide which one might be right for your needs. 

From engine power and deck sizes to wheelbase widths and turning radiuses — as well as price points — there are several aspects worth considering before making your purchase decision. Still, they are equally well-suited for basic mowing and yard work tasks around medium to large-sized yards.

The E170 has a slightly smaller engine yet more speed settings than its counterpart; meanwhile, the S170 boasts added power with slightly fewer speeds than its predecessor model.

Ultimately it comes down to personal preference – if you’re looking for something with more power but fewer speed settings, then go with the S170; if you’re looking for something with more versatility (more speed settings) but less power, then go with the E170! 

No matter your choice, you’ll have all your needs covered with either one of these top-quality lawn tractors from John Deere! 

5/5 - (6 votes)
error: Content is protected !!